Ver outras questões
Usar o filtro de questões
Ano: 2026
Banca:
Marinha
Órgão:
ESCOLA NAVAL
Prova:
Marinha - 2026 - ESCOLA NAVAL - Aspirante - 1º Dia |
Q4277328
Não definido
Texto associado
To Type or to Write, That Is the Question
At the highest level of learning, should you type or
write by hand?
[1] Research by Mueller and Oppenheimer (2014)
compared students who typed lecture notes on laptops
with those who wrote them by hand during the same time.
[2] In terms of immediate results, laptop users typed and
recorded more words during the lectures, and their notes
were aimost word-for-word transcripts of the lectures. The
initial assumption was that this would ultimately be
beneficial for these students compared with those who
were handwriting their notes.
[3] After the lectures, the two groups of students in this
study were tested on the information presented. The
results showed that students who wrote by hand during
lectures scored significantly higher on the tests than those
who typed.
[4] The immediate question was: "Why was this the case?"
Muelier and Oppenheimer (2014) found that students who
handwrote their notes were consistently engaged in higherlevel thinking. This meant that throughout their lectures,
these students were actively listening and intellectually
analyzing what to record. This led to higher knowledge-based outcomes.
[5] Luo et al. (2018) found that handwritten notes contained
more meaningful content (such as deeper thought and
greater intellectual structure), resulting in higher scores on
knowledge-based tests.
[6] Morehead et al. (2019) confirmed that the benefits of
handwriting are most evident when students are assessed
on higher-order conceptual understanding rather than on
memorizing facts.
[7] These studies confirm that handwriting is an essential
cognitive process and a highly beneficial intellectual
activity that enhances learning at advanced levels of
education and that begins from the first day of school and
continues thereafter.
Handwriting Helps to Advance Knowledge and
Enhance Ideas
[8] This evidence from university classrooms illustrates a
broader principle: handwriting for note-taking is a deeper
thinking skill. When students write by hand, they actively
select and synthesize information.
[9] This process requires them to decide what is essential,
how ideas connect, and how best to represent them in their
own words. The research indicates that this type of
engagement develops, advances, and enhances critical
thinking (defined as the ability to analyze, evaluate, and
make reasoned, detailed judgments), because handwriting
forces students to process information conceptually rather
than transcribe it verbatim.
[10] The research also indicates that this process helps to
develop higher-order thinking, which involves analyzing,
applying, synthesizing, and evaluating information. This
then develops a deeper knowledge potential. Additionally, as confirmed by classroom studies and evidence from
neuroscience, handwriting activates broader brain
networks than typing.
[11] Building on this, some studies explain that the ongoing
substitution of handwriting by typewriting in almost every
educational setting may seem somewhat misguided, as it
could negatively affect the learning process.
[12] However, Van der Weel and Van der Meer (2024)
emphasise the importance of staying current in this everchanging digital world. With this in mind, they state that
children must, first and foremost, learn handwriting. Only
after they are absoiutely proficient, especially at complex
narrative handwriting, should typing be considered.
(Adapted from: https://www.psychologytoday.com)
After tests were applied to students, the results
demonstrated that students who wrote by hand during the
lectures: