In his speech in Varginha, Pope Francis mentioned that one ...

Próximas questões
Com base no mesmo assunto
Ano: 2013 Banca: UECE-CEV Órgão: UECE Prova: UECE-CEV - 2013 - UECE - Vestibular - Língua Inglesa |
Q1308472 Inglês

TEXT



    RIO DE JANEIRO — Pope Francis on Thursday delivered some of his most politically provocative remarks since his papacy began this year, hopping from his popemobile to walk through a slum in this city before urging young people to fight against corruption, a leading grievance behind the huge street protests that shook dozens of Brazilian cities in June.
    “Do not grow accustomed to evil, but defeat it,” Francis said at the favela, or slum, of Varginha, in an area that has commonly been known here as the Gaza Strip for its gun battles and drug trafficking in the past. “Do not lose trust, do not allow your hope to be extinguished,” he added, acknowledging that it was common for some to “grow disillusioned with news of corruption.”
    By singling out corruption in a folksy visit to a Brazilian favela on his first trip abroad as pope, Francis, an Argentine-born Jesuit, emphasized his aim to refocus the Roman Catholic Church on the neglected margins of society, especially in Brazil and other parts of Latin America where the popularity of evangelical churches has surged among the poor in recent decades.
    In a nod to the Brazilian political authorities who have warmly welcomed him, Francis also praised the government’s antipoverty programs and did not specifically mention the anti-establishment protests in Brazil. But he did critique Rio de Janeiro’s so-called pacification project in the city’s slums, in which security forces assert control over lawless areas.
    “No amount of pacification will be able to last, nor will harmony and happiness be attained in a society that ignores, pushes to the margins or excludes a part of itself,” the pope said in Varginha, a slum that has recently been subjected to pacification. In a remark that could resonate in Latin America and in the United States, which is also grappling with the widening disparity between the haves and the have-nots, Francis said that a society “impoverishes itself” by perpetuating such inequality.
    Care for the poor and marginalized is an integral part of Catholic teaching, and a concern of many popes and encyclicals, including those by Francis’ predecessor, Benedict XVI. But Francis has made it a hallmark of his young papacy, telling journalists in Rome days after his election, “How I would like a church that is poor and for the poor.” He has demonstrated that ideal by living relatively humbly as pope: in a communal guesthouse rather than the opulent papal apartment, wearing a pectoral cross of iron instead of gold, flying commercial. He recently told priests that they should not drive fancy cars, and he has traveled around Rio this week in a compact Fiat.
    “He is helping to wake people up,” said Natalia Morais, 21, a nursing student from Minas Gerais State who traveled to Rio to see the pope as part of World Youth Day, a conference attended by hundreds of thousands of Catholic youth. “When the pope talks, political leaders listen, and that’s what’s needed in Brazil, where our protests are about their corruption,” Ms. Morais said.
    Reaching beyond Brazil, Francis told Argentines who came here for the conference that “the church must be taken into the streets” in a struggle against complacency. “Stir things up, cause confounding, but do not diminish faith in Jesus Christ,” he said in Spanish.
    In each of Francis’ public appearances, he has been accorded a rock-star reception. On an uncommonly cold and rainy morning, hundreds of residents lined the narrow, muddy sidewalks of the Varginha favela to glimpse the first pope from the Americas, who obliged by stopping often to touch and bless people.
    Many onlookers had made their own shirts to commemorate the event, with a photo of Francis. Others draped themselves in Brazilian flags and waved banners bearing his image. Residents darted in and out of their homes, checking their televisions and radios to learn the pope’s whereabouts and calling the information out to their neighbors standing on wet rooftops to get a better view.
    Sônia Curato, 48, a manicurist, said the pope’s visit was different from that of other leaders. “Politicians come all the time. They make promises and leave,” she said. “He is a very simple person. You can tell that. He has charisma. He speaks to the people, doesn’t like going around in an armored car.”


By Simon Romero and Taylor Barnes
Published: July 25, 2013
www.nytimes.com

In his speech in Varginha, Pope Francis mentioned that one of his aims in the Papacy is 
Alternativas

Gabarito comentado

Confira o gabarito comentado por um dos nossos professores

Gabarito: A

Fundamento decisivo: A resposta decorre da identificação explícita do trecho “Francis, an Argentine-born Jesuit, emphasized his aim to refocus the Roman Catholic Church on the neglected margins of society”, que corresponde à formulação da alternativa A.

Tema central: objetivo declarado do papado
Análise das alternativas
A
Certa
A alternativa A está correta porque corresponde semanticamente ao trecho expresso no texto: “refocus the Roman Catholic Church on the neglected margins of society”. O núcleo do objetivo é redirecionar a atenção da Igreja para os grupos socialmente marginalizados ou negligenciados. A formulação “forgotten part of society” é uma paráfrase fiel de “neglected margins of society”, sem acrescentar nem distorcer o conteúdo.
B
Errada
Incorreta por introduzir informação inexistente no texto. Não há menção a objetivo do papado ligado a levar mais crianças para escolas católicas. A eliminação decorre de confronto direto com o texto, que trata de foco da Igreja nos marginalizados, e não de política educacional escolar.
C
Errada
Incorreta porque confunde um detalhe descritivo sobre o estilo de vida do papa com um objetivo institucional do papado. O texto menciona que ele vive em “a communal guesthouse rather than the opulent papal apartment” como sinal de simplicidade pessoal; não afirma projeto de construir mais guesthouses nem apresenta isso como uma de suas metas.
D
Errada
Incorreta por erro de referente e por extrapolação. No texto, “Gaza Strip” é um apelido local de uma área de Varginha, associado a seu histórico de violência, e não o território real do Oriente Médio. Além disso, o texto não declara como objetivo do papado “extinguishing gun-battles”; essa formulação não é afirmada.
Pegadinha da questão
A banca combina três confusões reais: troca o trecho correto por uma paráfrase na alternativa certa, usa em C uma informação verdadeira do texto mas sem relação com o que foi perguntado, e em D explora a leitura literal indevida de “Gaza Strip”, que no texto é apenas um apelido local.
Dica para questões semelhantes
  • Quando a pergunta pedir objetivo, localize no texto expressões como “aim” ou formulações equivalentes antes de comparar as alternativas.
  • Reconheça paráfrase semântica fiel como resposta correta quando ela reproduzir a ideia central do trecho.
  • Elimine alternativas que usem detalhes reais do texto, mas mudem sua função: descrição pessoal não vira meta institucional.
  • Controle o referente de nomes e expressões do texto para não tomar apelido, metáfora ou contexto local como referência literal externa.

Clique para visualizar este gabarito

Visualize o gabarito desta questão clicando no botão abaixo