According to Text I, it is correct to affirm that: 

Próximas questões
Com base no mesmo assunto
Q3414342 Inglês

Read Text I and answer question.


Is social media harming teens? A dive into the research cites risks but returns few hard answers 


A new report from the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine grapples with the questions: Is social media harming teenagers? And what can Congress, the Education Department and parents do about it?


The answers are murky. The authors surveyed hundreds of studies across more than a decade and came to complicated, occasionally contradictory, conclusions. On one hand, they found there isn’t enough population data to specifically blame social media for changes in adolescent health. On the other hand, as shown in study after study cited by the report, social media has the clear potential to hurt the health of teenagers, and in situations where a teenager is already experiencing difficulties like a mental health crisis, social media tends to make it worse.


“There is much we still don’t know, but our report lays out a clear path forward for both pursuing the biggest unanswered questions about youth health and social media, and taking steps that can minimize the risk to young people using social media now,” Sandro Galea, dean of the Boston University School of Public Health and chair of the committee behind the report, said in a news release.


According to the report, the ways social media is used seem to make a difference. When a teenager passively scrolls, as opposed to actively posting, that’s connected by many studies to low life satisfaction and feelings of sadness. It may be that showcasing a hobby or an interest on social media doesn’t produce the same harms. But those rates differ by demographic group: Black, non-Hispanic participants in one study reported more negative moods during active social media use, suggesting that the potential benefits of posting on social media are not the same for teenagers of all backgrounds.


In addition, age affects how well certain strategies work. In younger children, a family policy that restricts social media except when it’s actively guided by a parent seems to reduce the risk of problematic use and inappropriate behavior online. But in adolescents, overly restrictive and controlling parental rules, like confiscating a phone for punishment, are often associated with that teenager taking more risks online.


Faced with an urgent need to “create a more transparent industry and a better-informed consumer of social media,” the report calls on companies and regulators to establish international standards, such as clear ways for companies to share data with researchers and accepted best practices to avoid proven harms where possible. It recommends that the International Organization for Standardization – a body that sets global rules in areas such as manufacturing and food safety – be tasked with creating a new system, one that could be used by federal and international agencies to track and evaluate social media companies and the algorithms they build. And it asks for funding from the National Institutes of Health, the National Science Foundation and other agencies to pay for the sort of large, long-term studies that have in the past identified major public health crises.


Adapted from: https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/socialmedia/social-media-harming-teens-dive-research-citesrisks-returns-hard-answ-rcna129490  

According to Text I, it is correct to affirm that: 
Alternativas

Gabarito comentado

Confira o gabarito comentado por um dos nossos professores

Alternativa correta: B

Tema central da questão:

Esta questão aborda a interpretação de texto (reading comprehension) em língua inglesa, focando em identificar informações explícitas e inferências sobre o impacto das redes sociais na saúde mental de adolescentes e em como diferentes estratégias de controle parental influenciam esse uso.

Resumo teórico:

O texto destaca que o efeito das redes sociais nos adolescentes ainda é objeto de discussão: embora não haja dados populacionais suficientes para responsabilizar apenas as redes sociais por mudanças na saúde mental, há indícios claros de que podem agravar problemas já existentes. Quanto à família, regras excessivamente rígidas e punitivas tendem a trazer resultados opostos ao desejado, levando os adolescentes a se arriscarem mais online.

Justificativa da alternativa correta (B):

A alternativa B afirma que regras parentais excessivamente restritivas em adolescentes tendem a ter efeito contrário ao esperado. Essa afirmação é confirmada pelo trecho: “But in adolescents, overly restrictive and controlling parental rules, like confiscating a phone for punishment, are often associated with that teenager taking more risks online.”

Ou seja, o controle exagerado não protege, mas pode estimular comportamentos de risco.

Análise das alternativas incorretas:

A: Fala de “maior expectativa de vida” para quem posta ativamente, o que não é mencionado no texto. O texto discute satisfação e humor, não longevidade.

C e D: Ambas afirmam que as redes sociais são a única causa das mudanças na saúde mental dos adolescentes, o que contradiz o texto, que diz expressamente: “there isn’t enough population data to specifically blame social media for changes in adolescent health”. Ou seja, não há comprovação de que as redes sociais sejam o único fator.

Estratégias para interpretação:

Ao ler o enunciado e as alternativas, procure palavras absolutas como “only”, “higher life expectancy” e verifique se o texto realmente traz essas afirmações. Muitas pegadinhas aparecem quando a alternativa exagera ou distorce a informação original.

Lembre-se também de identificar conceitos-chave, como “passively scrolling” versus “actively posting” e “overly restrictive parental rules”, para reconhecer as comparações feitas pelo texto.

Gostou do comentário? Deixe sua avaliação aqui embaixo!

Clique para visualizar este gabarito

Visualize o gabarito desta questão clicando no botão abaixo