The Muslim preference for animals such as birds and scorpion...
Text 5 for questions from 41 to 44.
1 _____ In the pre-dawn of June 16th , a lone voice broke the
stillness. The mullahs summoned the men to prayers; for two
hours the priests called and the men responded in a gathering
4 rhythmic crescendo to psych them up to fight and die.
The defenders crouched behind their makeshift barricades,
listening to the eerie chants rising and falling in the darkness
7 beyond. La Vallete had sent reinforcements across and the
defenders, if already weary, were well ordered. Each man had
his duty and his post. They were grouped in threes: one
10 arquebusier to two pikemen. Large quantities of fire weapons
had been stock piled, rocks gathered, and quantities of bread
soaked in wine. Barrels of water stood behind the parapets into
13 which men torched by adhesive fire could hurl themselves.
_____ As the sun rose, there was a searching barrage of fire
‘so that the earth and the air shook’, and then Mustapha
16 signalled the advance along a huge crescent. Suleiman’s
imperial standard was unfurled; a turban was hoisted on a
spear, farther down the line there was an answering puff of
19 smoke. An extraordinary array of banners and shields were
visible surging forward, ‘painted with extraordinary designs;
some with devices of different birds, some with scorpions and
22 with Arab lettering’. In the front rank men ran wildly towards
the walls, calling out the name of Allah in a crescendo of
shouts. From the battlements came the Christian countercalls:
25 Jesus, Mary, St Michael, St James and St George — ‘according
to the devotion of each man’. There was a furious push towards
the bridge; scaling ladders were put to the walls and battle was
28 joined. The whole front was a struggling mass of humanity
fighting hand to hand.
Roger Crowley. Empires of the Sea, The Final Battle for the
Mediterranean, 1521-1580, Faber and Faber, 2008, p. 1-2.
Concerning the battle proper, decide based on the text if the following statements are right (C) or wrong (E).
The Muslim preference for animals such as birds and scorpions suggests that they are wild warriors.
Gabarito comentado
Confira o gabarito comentado por um dos nossos professores
A alternativa correta para a questão é E - errado.
Vamos analisar o texto para entender o porquê dessa resposta. O trecho descreve uma cena de batalha onde há um confronto entre muçulmanos e cristãos. Os muçulmanos são descritos como tendo uma variedade de estandartes e escudos com desenhos extraordinários, incluindo pássaros e escorpiões, além de inscrições em árabe.
A questão sugere que a preferência dos muçulmanos por esses motivos visuais implica que eles são guerreiros selvagens. No entanto, essa interpretação não é sustentada pelo texto. Os detalhes sobre os desenhos se referem mais a um aspecto cultural e estilístico dos estandartes e escudos, ao invés de uma indicação direta sobre o comportamento ou natureza dos guerreiros.
Assim, a afirmativa é considerada incorreta porque não é possível inferir a selvageria dos guerreiros muçulmanos apenas a partir dos animais e símbolos que decoravam seus escudos e estandartes. O texto não faz essa conexão direta.
Gostou do comentário? Deixe sua avaliação aqui embaixo!
Clique para visualizar este gabarito
Visualize o gabarito desta questão clicando no botão abaixo